Civil Service Spens Cup results for 2012

Spens Cup - 2012

Date	Opponent	Venue	Result	Score
	Kilmarnock	Home	Draw	3 - 3
	Edinburgh B	Home	Win	5½ - ½
	Irvine	Home	Loss	2 - 4

Scorecards

	Civil Service		Civil Service		Kilmarnock		Kilmarnock
1	Alan R Prince	1844	½ - ½	Douglas Hamilton	1862
2	Crawford T MacNab	1786	½ - ½	Joe Parks	1860
3	Rudolph J Austin	1693	½ - ½	James P R Kleboe	1749
4	Douglas S Heatlie	1587	0 - 1	Jamie Malkin	1726
5	Richard Scott	1568	1 - 0	James W Armour	1641
6	Simon Bate	1560	½ - ½	Ian Muir	1434
				3 - 3

	Civil Service		Civil Service		Edinburgh B		Edinburgh B
1	Alan R Prince	1844	1 - 0	Michael Ridge	1892
2	Crawford T MacNab	1786	1 - 0	Lindsay A McGregor	1804
3	Douglas S Heatlie	1587	1 - 0	Christopher McIntee	1725
4	Simon Bate	1560	½ - ½	A Keith Aitchison	1640
5	Gerry Brown	1424	1 - 0	Alastair Girvan	1557
6	George C Anderson	1329	1 - 0	Calum McGillivray	1314
				5½ - ½

	Civil Service		Civil Service		Irvine		Irvine
1	Alan R Prince	1844	½ - ½	Graeme E King	1738
2	Crawford T MacNab	1786	0 - 1	Philip F Walsh	1717
3	Rudolph J Austin	1693	1 - 0	Alan J Birnie	1691
4	Douglas S Heatlie	1587	0 - 1	Robert Gourlay	1529
5	Richard Scott	1568	0 - 1	Robert Loughran	1512
6	Gerry Brown	1424	½ - ½	Graeme Forbes	1313
				2 - 4